What is better for the child - to read fairy tales or listen to them in audio performance?

It's no secret that modern children do not like to read. Meanwhile, the child is obliged to read as much as possible: it is the books that are read that in many ways make him a full-fledged personality. How can you make him read? Rather, how can one instill in a child a love for a book? One of the most recent answers to this question is this: since children do not like to read books, let them listen to them in audio performance.

Parents: reading or listening is the question ...

It is clear that parents are most concerned about this issue. Should children read books or should they listen to them? There are ongoing ongoing parental disputes on this subject. As usual, there is no unequivocal opinion in these disputes. Here are just some of the parental opinions taken on the Internet:

• It is better, of course, if the child reads himself. When children read, they automatically replenish their vocabulary. When listening to audiobooks, their vocabulary is not replenished;
• When a child reads on his own, he develops visual and creative imagination. But when the baby does not read, but only listens - this is the best way grow a lazy dog ​​out of him;
• It all depends on the nature and temperament of the child. Someone is better to listen to, someone - to read;
• Reading is better than listening anyway. Moreover, the books have colorful pictures. Children love pictures, they consider them, fantasize, imagine themselves in the place of heroes. Audiobook does not give room for imagination. As a result, listening to audio, an adult grows out of a child, unable to think abstractly;
• If a child listens to audio with headphones, it almost inevitably affects his hearing;
• A lot depends on what level of audiobook is and what it says. A quality audio book also helps develop children's imagination. Even more so than looking at pictures. Everything is clear with the pictures: here is the positive hero, and here is the negative. And when a child listens to an audiobook, then he must imagine his characters - both positive and negative. In particular, if an audiobook is not a monotonous murmur of a single reader, but a full-fledged audio performance, voiced by different voices;
• If a child is small, then, of course, it would be better if his mother, father, grandmother or grandfather reads a book. Such reading is very important. Firstly, a particularly confidential contact is established between the baby and those who read the book to him. Secondly, a child can always ask mom or dad, grandparents to explain some strange places to him.It is better to listen to audio books for those children who are older, kids need to read books;
• Now children are already raising a TV and the Internet. Let the tired mother or grandmother mumble about the wolf and seven kids. In any case, with mom or grandmother it is warmer than with a soulless audiobook;
• If you want to make a moron out of a child, make him listen to audio books from an early age. Do you want your baby to become a thinking and creative person - let him read “the old fashioned way”. That is, at first parents or grandparents read to him, and then he himself.

As you can see, parental opinions on this issue are very different. Some parents are opposed to audio books and advocate exclusively for reading. Others - do not see anything bad and harmful for children in audiobooks. Still others are in favor of intelligently combining listening to audiobooks and classical reading.

Psychologists, doctors and scientists about the benefits of audio books for children

And now let us listen to what scientists, psychologists and doctors say about the benefits and dangers of audio books for children. The opinions here are also very different. Some argue that audio books are modern and can not do any harm to children, others claim that it is not so much useful as harmful. To begin with, what kind of benefit can listening to an audiobook by a kid.

When the baby listens to audio books, he develops a memory. After listening to the audio story, the baby will most likely want to share what he heard and remember with people close to him: mom, dad, grandparents, older brothers or sisters. Thus, the baby trains and develops his memory. In addition, retelling what he heard, the child develops his speech.

Usually, children's audiobooks are voiced by professional artists. Listening to professional voice acting, the child involuntarily imitates actor's intonations, learns the correct pronunciation of words and phrases. In addition, professionally voiced audio books help children to develop primary artistic data and the ability to communicate. Such data and such a skill can be very useful in later life. In many audio fairy tales, classical music sounds, listening to which, the baby develops musicality and a high aesthetic taste.

Since children spend a lot of time at lessons, as well as at computers and TVs, their eyes get tired. As a result, vision may deteriorate. And when a child listens to an audiobook, his eyes rest. In addition, listening to fairy tales and tales in audio, children will watch less harmful television programs for the psyche.

Children's audio fairy tales play a big role in cases when parents and their children ride in vehicles, stand in line, are in some kind of public institution, etc. It often happens that the baby gets tired and gets naughty in such cases. In this case, it is not always possible to entertain a child with an ordinary book. A player with headphones is more useful here (so as not to disturb those who are nearby). Practice shows that the audiobook helps to reassure the child much more successfully.

Psychologists, doctors and scientists about the dangers of audio books for children

It often happens that a child who is used to listening to audio books categorically refuses to read on his own. He develops a kind of bias in the perception of information. By ear, he will perceive the information remarkably, but as for visual perception, there can be serious problems. And reorienting it to reading is usually very difficult.

[sc name = ”rsa”]

Many parents believe that a player with an audiobook can be a kind of “substitute” for father and mother. That is, in the opinion of such parents, it is the player who should educate and educate their child, while the parents are engaged in the extraction of "daily bread." Of course, this opinion is fundamentally wrong. No player and no audio tales can replace parental warmth.

When a child often uses headphones, this will almost certainly affect his hearing.It is better, of course, to listen through the speakers, but in this case, a loud sound can interfere with other households. The way out here is this. Firstly, headphones must be of high quality, and secondly, headphones must be alternated with speakers.

Well, what to do?

What to do in this case is a difficult question. To prohibit a child from listening to audio books is, of course, not an option. Yes, this is not necessary, since listening to audio books is not only harmful, but also beneficial. As well as a good old reading.

Therefore, it will be best if the child alternates between listening and reading. In this case, he will learn to perceive information in two ways - visually and by ear. It is clear that the child must be convinced of this. But this is a topic for another discussion.

We also read:

• How to instill in your child a love of books and reading
• Books and children, or how to interest a child in reading: The expert named 3 rules for how to read books with a child
• The effect of fairy tales on child development
• Bedtime Stories - A Pleasant Bedtime Ritual
• "Bedtime story" or why gadgets can not replace the child's book?

The opinion of mummies: Is it better for a child to read fairy tales or include audio tales?

It is better to communicate more with the child, including reading fairy tales to him or composing them herself or with the child, which is much more interesting. But sometimes you can include audio tales. I do this when there is absolutely no time to be with the child before going to bed, or rather, there is no way to read. Although this, of course, is a miserable “excuse” ...

***

If you have the time and energy - of course, to read it yourself, you communicate with the child in this way, keep in touch with him. It’s the same as listening to live music or singing and recording - this is about the value of perception. But the most important thing, as I said, is live communication, the child will ask you questions. So I remember from childhood there was some kind of fairy tale about a fox, a wolf, and there were some other options - from the point of view of each of the characters, maybe 100 times her mother told me and I asked questions every time and now we are with her we all remember that.

***

No audio tale can replace the pleasant voice of your beloved dad or mom. In addition, telling, and not reading a fairy tale, the narrator adds a little any new circumstances from himself, which makes any popular and well-known tale (of the same Kolobok) a more attractive and interesting story. A pleasant fairy tale with an interesting and good ending, told by a loved one, and not by a voice from a gadget, will make the child’s sleep sound and healthy, any child psychologist will tell you about it.